Questions

What Is Christian Nationalism?

By James Spencer Last updated

Summary: Christian nationalism is the collapsing of a distinction between church and state in which the church employs a political logic and redefines its mission, to some extent, in terms of political wins and losses. It mixes non-religious ideology, often conservatism, with civil religion, reinforcing the governing authorities while diminishing the Church. Christians should resist it not because political engagement is wrong but because it confuses the Church’s mission with the state’s power.

Direct Answer

Christian nationalism is the collapsing of a distinction between church and state in which the church employs a political logic, redefining its mission, to some extent, in terms of political wins and losses. The fusion of Christianity and the state represents an odd mix of non-religious ideology, often conservatism, and civil religion. Christian nationalism reinforces the governing authorities while diminishing the Church through a merger of theological assertions and political power. Christian nationalism assumes, at least implicitly, that the Church and its witness, apart from the state’s coercive power, is insufficient.

Discussion

Borrowing from George Orwell, who describes nationalism as "power hunger tempered by self-deception," Christian nationalism may be understood as a movement seeking to gain political power through a fictional vision of America supported by selective (and inappropriate) uses of biblical texts and other Christian terms. The selective use of the Bible and other Christian terms advances a distorted form of Christianity. Many people, some Christians included, seem incapable of distinguishing genuine Christian claims and aims from those of Christian nationalism. As such, it seems appropriate that we may speak of "harder" and "softer," or perhaps "self-aware" and "coincidental," versions of Christian nationalism.

Regarding the differing claims of Christianity and Christian nationalism, we see that Christ is indispensable to the former and nonessential to the latter. For instance, Neighborly Faith found that "Christian nationalist adherents" strongly agree with the statement, "The true culture of the United States is fundamentally Christian." Such a claim is unintelligible from the perspective of the Christian faith because "Christian" denotes the mixed multitude of Jews and non-Jews united in Jesus Christ by faith, as well as their shared beliefs and practices governed by the biblical text and refined through repentance. A "Christian" culture, then, would be the medium in which those united in Christ display God's vision of a meaningful life by learning to live under Christ's authority. It is not a culture inspired by biblical ideas abstracted from their theological context.

Christian nationalism is problematic because it blurs the distinction between the church and the state, two institutions God has established with different purposes. The state is tasked with maintaining a measure of justice and peace within society, often through limited human judgment and the use of coercive authority. The church, however, is a community formed by faith in Christ and empowered by the Holy Spirit to proclaim the gospel, make disciples, and model a life shaped by obedience to God. When these two institutions are merged, the unique calling of the church is easily overshadowed by political goals. Instead of pointing beyond political systems to the coming kingdom of God, the church can become invested in preserving the authority and success of the state. As Joseph Mangina notes in his commentary on Revelation: "The church that imagines it has a successful strategy for confronting the principalities and powers on their own terms had better think again."

From the Book

The rest of this page is drawn from chapter one of James Spencer, Serpents and Doves: Christians, Politics, and the Art of Bearing Witness to Jesus (2024). The chapter works through the five statements researchers use to measure Christian nationalism and explains why each one diminishes the Church.

In February of 2023, the Public Religion Research Institute (PRRI) released a research report titled “A Christian Nation? Understanding the Threat of Christian Nationalism to American Democracy and Culture.” The report analyzed American perspectives on Christian nationalism by asking Americans to disclose their level of agreement with the following statements:

  • The U.S. government should declare America a Christian nation.
  • U.S. laws should be based on Christian values.
  • If the U.S. moves away from our Christian foundations, we will not have a country anymore.
  • Being Christian is an important part of being truly American.
  • God has called Christians to exercise dominion over all areas of American society.

The results of the report underscore the political polarization within the United States today. Whereas more than 50% of Republicans surveyed qualified as either Christian nationalism adherents (21%) or sympathizers (33%), 75% of independents and 83% of Democrats were either skeptics or rejecters. Given the five statements above, it seems clear that there are, at the very least, significant disagreements about our country’s history and the Establishment and Free Exercise clauses in the First Amendment.

The political polarization is, however, less concerning than the correlations between Christianity and Christian nationalism. The PRRI found that many groups within Christianity qualified as either Christian nationalism sympathizers or adherents. Note the following:

  • White evangelical Protestant: 35% sympathizer; 29% adherent
  • Other Protestant of color: 32% sympathizer; 20% adherent
  • Hispanic Protestant: 23% sympathizer; 20% adherent
  • Black Protestant: 24% sympathizer; 14% adherent
  • Other Christian: 22% sympathizer; 13% adherent

The report notes that self-identified evangelical or born-again Christians were almost five times as likely to be Christian nationalism adherents when compared with those who self-identify as Christian but not as evangelical.

The statements used in the PRRI survey offer a helpful starting point for thinking through the relationship between Church and state. The statements tend to collapse, or at the very least confuse, the distinction between the Church and the state. As such, those who agree with such statements are making theological errors that diminish the Church while elevating the state. They advocate for a distorted understanding of the Church. While integrating Christianity into government may seem to privilege the Church, I would argue the opposite is actually the case: the Church is diluted and diminished. This assertion will become more obvious when these statements are dissected.

Statement 1: The U.S. government should declare America a Christian nation.

Calling America a “Christian nation” blurs the lines between Church and state. As members of the Church in the United States, describing any nation as “Christian” applies a meaning of “Christian” different than that found in the Bible. In the biblical references, Christ is essential to the meaning of “Christian.” At no point in our nation’s history was Christ essential to our national identity.

Beyond that, I would argue that no nation, including the United States, can be Christian in a properly biblical sense. The Bible uses “Christian” to refer to the mixed multitude of Jews and non-Jews united in Christ. It is difficult to imagine that a pluralistic nation committed to (a) religious freedom, (b) the consent of the governed, and (c) precluding the establishment of religion by the state, could ever be characterized as Christian. At the very least, it would seem that as long as non-Christians have equal opportunity to, for instance, pursue political office, vote, or believe and speak about their convictions without fearing the coercive power of the state, no nation, including the United States, would remain “Christian” for long.

Statement 2: U.S. laws should be based on Christian values.

It isn’t clear that Christ is essential to “Christian values.” Because God’s order is all-encompassing, its basic structure is theologically rooted. God, in other words, may be denied, but such denial does not negate his existence or authority. Values cannot be disconnected from that theological structure without deforming those values in some way. It is not that there can be no values or morality apart from the Triune God. Rather, values and morality decoupled from an established authority are subject to and determined by human judgment. Biblically, human judgment unguided by or in opposition to God is responsible for the tragedies currently facing humankind (Gen 3:1-7; Num 15:39; Deut 12:8; Judg 17:6; 21:25). To put it differently, values and morality separated from the theological reality of God are mis-ordered loves because God’s place as the first and foremost love is denied.

So, what are “Christian values”? If stated as a hierarchy, the utmost Christian “value” is allegiance to (or love for) the Triune God (Matt 22:37). Christians value the glorification of God above all things. As such, all we are and have is to be devoted to him (Deut 6:4-5). Loving our neighbor follows from loving God. Christians value justice, impartiality, mercy, freedom, etc. Yet, Christian values cannot be separated from their natural theological context. They are not opinions or preferences. They are realities.

Christian values may overlap with those espoused by non-Christians. However, non-Christian values cannot encompass or embody Christian values because Christian values are rooted in theological realities such as Christ’s resurrection. Whereas Christian values emanate from our commitment to the triumphant lamb or the glorification of God, non-Christian values pursue the maintenance of a particular conception of the world that may tolerate, but not embrace or acknowledge, Christ as the one “in whom are hidden all the treasures of wisdom and knowledge” (Col 2:3).

There is a sense in which such values echo God’s created order. As such, Christians and non-Christians may find common ground to a point. However, a general agreement with such values is not sufficient to describe those values as “Christian” or “biblical.” Using such language to describe values expressed in the political realm gives the appearance that the theological aspect of “Christian values” is at best secondary to the consensus of those who are part of the Christian community. The consensus of the community is not unimportant. Traditions can be helpful; however, when consensus begins to overshadow the authority of God, the Church is no longer following Christ but its own intuition and judgment (cf. Matt 15:1-9).

Statement 3: If the U.S. moves away from our Christian foundations, we will not have a country anymore.

First, this statement is problematic because it assumes the United States actually has a Christian foundation. While there is a way of describing the history of the United States as Christian, the word “Christian” in such descriptions takes on a meaning in which Christ is not central. While predominantly Protestant, non-Christians also participated in America’s founding. We also see various decisions early in the formation of the United States not to tie America explicitly to Christianity. For instance, various proposals suggesting that Christ be added to the United States’ founding documents were rejected at the state and federal level. Suggesting that the United States had “Christian foundations” does not gesture to an early commitment to Christ that was lost along the way. Instead, it refers to the various ways Western society and the United States adapted and borrowed moral frameworks from the Bible and the Christian faith while leaving the theological convictions aside.

Second, beyond the assumption that America has a Christian founding, there are a host of nations that would not claim to have been “Christian” at their founding yet survived (and thrived) far longer than the United States has at this point or are still in existence. Many of those nations may outlast the United States. Historically, for example, the Roman Empire lasted over 1,000 years and was in no way, shape, or form “Christian” at its founding. The United States is less than 250 years old. To correlate the duration of our nation with its Christian founding requires that we assume (at least implicitly) that the United States has a special understanding of and with the Triune God. Such an assumption is pure conjecture.

Clearly, when foreign nations responded appropriately to prophetic messages, they avoided disaster and destruction. For instance, after Jonah delivers God’s word to Nineveh, the Ninevites repent (Jon 3:6-10). Some broad, collective repentance in response to the Church’s preaching could be deemed national repentance today as well. However, what is needed is not a return to some imagined past but a widespread turning to the Lord. That won’t be accomplished through political control but through the witness of the Church and the work of the Holy Spirit.

Statement 4: Being Christian is an important part of being truly American.

Suggesting that being Christian is involved in being “truly American” raises questions about the relationship between being Christian and being a member of a particular nation. As such, this statement, perhaps more than the others, blurs the boundary between “Christian” and “American.” In doing so, it diminishes what it means to be Christian. We are, after all, sojourners and exiles (1 Pet 2:11), citizens of heaven (Phil 3:20), and members of God’s household (Eph 2:11-19). We live within a nation, but we belong to another kingdom. In fact, our task is not to produce more moral Americans, but to call Americans to become citizens of heaven along with us and to acknowledge an authority that transcends that of America’s governing authorities.

Christians believe nations have delegated authority from God. We obey our governing authorities as an extension of our obedience to God. As such, Christians are to “silence the ignorance of foolish people” “by doing good” (1 Pet 2:15). In this sense, Christians are (or at least can be considered) good citizens. However, this sense of being a good citizen has little to do with being a true American and far more with being a faithful Christian. Christians will often need to stand opposed to governing authorities as they serve God rather than men (Acts 5:29). As such, we do not aim to be “truly American” but to be disciples of Jesus Christ who accept that we may be hated by the world (John 15:18-19) and, by extension, our nation.

Statement 5: God has called Christians to exercise dominion over all areas of American society.

Christianity grew up in the Roman Empire. Christ appeared before the Roman officials. After Jesus’s resurrection and ascension, Christ’s followers made disciples among the Jews and Gentiles throughout the Roman Empire. While God’s people grew in number, Christians did not seek to overthrow Rome. If they sought to reform Roman society, they did so by becoming an alternative community committed to proclaiming Christ in word and deed.

“Exercising dominion” in the context of the United States suggests some sort of coercive Christian influence. Instead of extending Christ’s authority through discipleship, “exercising dominion” assumes that Christians should determine and enforce laws, adjudicate legal cases, and oversee the various functions of government. While I believe Christians are free, like other American citizens, to pursue and hold government offices, I do not believe coordinated efforts to dominate American society in the name of Christ are biblically warranted. As such, they would not serve the interests of the gospel.

First, coordinated efforts to dominate society would seem to run against the spirit of Paul’s instruction in 1 Corinthians 7:17-24. In this passage, Paul encourages the Corinthians to use their current circumstances to serve the Lord rather than seeking to change those circumstances so that they can serve the Lord. In other words, we don’t need to fix America before we serve God. Paul’s argument is not that our social situation is unimportant. Rather, his point is that our circumstances do not curtail the Church’s ability to do God’s work. Nothing needs to change for Christians to be faithful.

Second, some may argue that “fixing America” and “serving God” are not mutually exclusive. There is a sense in which this is true. My point in setting them at odds is not to suggest that Christians should abandon the state. Instead, it is to suggest that fixing America often involves mechanisms of action that minimize the tasks of witnessing and disciple-making. In seeking to make America the “shining city on a hill,” we have too often neglected the task of being lights ourselves. Christians are to serve God regardless of whether America is fixed or not. Fixing America may well be a consequence of the Church’s worship of God; however, the Church cannot fix America without first being the Church.

Third, the Church, by its nature, serves the Lord, who has been given all authority in heaven and on earth. The Church does not exercise dominion because it is built to serve God and, by extension, others. In seeking to exercise dominion in the political realm, we will almost assuredly become servants of the political realm. We will become servants of the world’s politics because we must pursue dominion on terms set by the world. Those terms are problematic because we are to live on Christ’s terms. We have been called to witness to the Lordship of Christ, to make disciples, and to “bind and loose” (Matt 16:19; 18:18). The Church cannot overreach by exercising authority beyond what it has been given. To do so diminishes the Church and calls God’s wisdom into question.

Finally, if Christians are to “exercise dominion over all areas of American society,” that dominion does not involve taking over the state’s role. Instead, our dominion is exercised as we “abstain from the passions of the flesh” (1 Pet 2:11). It is demonstrated as we act honorably among the nations (2:12). Our dominion is not evident when we play the world’s political games by the world’s political rules (even when we win). Instead, our dominion is evident when we play a completely different game according to different rules. It is evident when we “obey God rather than men” (Acts 5:29).

Christian nationalism is theologically problematic, particularly when understood in terms of the above statements. Each of the statements above suggests a merger of some sort between church and state. Setting aside for the moment the political questions such a merger raises, Christians should be concerned with the way these statements blur the boundaries between the Church and the state. Maintaining the Church’s distinctive role and identity is crucial to its ongoing mission of pointing to and magnifying the Triune God. Unlike the Church, the state is not set apart to serve Christ by bearing witness. To collapse the distinction between the two is a theological error.

Separating Church from State

In 1801, the Danbury Baptist Association of Connecticut wrote to Thomas Jefferson, who had recently been elected as the president of the United States. They sought Jefferson’s assurance that he would uphold the First Amendment’s prohibition on state-established religion. At the time, Connecticut had established the Congregational Church as the official state church and was allocating state funds to support it. The Danbury Baptists hoped the like-minded Jefferson would not add to the problem of state-established churches by compromising the First Amendment at the federal level.

Jefferson’s official response was issued on January 1, 1802. He affirmed his solidarity with the Danbury Baptists, noting, “I contemplate with sovereign reverence that act of the whole American people which declared that their legislature should ‘make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof,’ thus building a wall of separation between Church and State.”

The “wall of separation” was intended to maintain a distinction between the Church and the government. The legislature was not to coerce the Church, nor was the Church to wield or direct the state’s power.

Jefferson was not suggesting that religious individuals or groups be precluded from participating in the democratic process. Christians, individually and collectively, were (and are) free to participate in politics. As a principle of government, the state would not police or establish the religious beliefs of its citizens. As Jefferson notes, “the legitimate powers of government reach actions only, and not opinions.” Jefferson’s distinction between action and [religious] opinion reflects one of the difficulties of liberalism, the basic philosophy on which U.S. politics are based: it assumes that a rational, principled neutrality can be achieved when such a neutral position is not possible. It cannot be neutral because judgment is required to “reach actions.” The “legitimate powers of government” also “reach… opinions.”

The founders could not have created an ideologically neutral government. Governing authorities must exercise judgment. Judgment assumes a point of view and framework for sense-making. The founders could guard against specific threats (e.g., the state establishment of religion), but they couldn’t help but create a system of governing principles that could be deformed and corrupted. As wise as America’s founders may have been, the government they established was bound to be flawed.

For instance, though the founders sought to keep state and religion separate by prohibiting state-established religion, governing authorities remain susceptible to ideological positions arising from (a) specific interest groups or (b) the public at large. Some of these ideological positions are comparable to religions though they are not classified as such. Because they are not classified as religions, the state can exercise coercive power to establish these ideologies. While allowing religious institutions to have undue influence over governing authorities was and is problematic, religious institutions are not the only danger. Ideologically driven positions (e.g., Christian nationalism, LGBTQ+, DEI, etc.) may not be classified as “religion,” yet the dynamics created by state establishment of such ideologies seem suspiciously similar to the sort of undue influence the founders of our nation were seeking to avoid in the First Amendment.

In addition to ideologies outside the state, civil religion is also a problem that was left largely unaddressed in America’s founding documents. The state often presumes to be moving in concert with God. The state’s “liturgies” cultivate a loyalty to the state. Even when such liturgies acknowledge that the state is “under God,” they tend to allow the state to call the shots rather than acknowledging the authority of God on a more practical level. The political power of the state begins to define the sacred and profane and to conform citizens so that they respect and embody those notions of sacred and profane. In doing so, the state institutes civil religion.

Suggesting that the government is susceptible to non-religious ideologies or prone to institute a civil religion may appear to be an argument for Christian nationalism. It’s not. Christian nationalism isn’t the answer because the fusion of Christianity and the state represents an odd mix of non-religious ideology and civil religion. Christian nationalism expands the scope of governing authorities while diminishing the role of the Church and the power it brings to bear on the world through the Holy Spirit.

Christian nationalism assumes, at least implicitly, that the Church and its witness, apart from the state’s coercive power, is insufficient. The Church needs the political realm to make the world a better place. Unfortunately, when Church and state become intertwined, the Church is likely to be less capable of criticizing governing authorities. A diminished witness is surely not an appropriate goal for God’s people. As such, the theological distinction between Church and state must govern the Church’s understanding of the separation of Church and state.

Distinguishing Church and State to Separate Church and State

Both the Church and the world sit under the Triune God’s authority. However, the Church acknowledges that authority and is constituted as a permanent community united in Jesus Christ. The Church is not founded on opinion. By acknowledging (not theoretically positing) God’s authority, the Church points beyond any sort of order the state could hope to provide without denying the God-given role of the state. The Church recognizes the state as provisional but not trivial.

The state’s task is to pursue and maintain some sense of justice and peace within society. Still, the state can never achieve the final social arrangement God will institute through the creation of the new heavens and new earth (Rev 21:1-27). The state will always miss the mark in accomplishing its God-given task. The Church is a constant reminder of the state’s limitations because it anticipates a future state unachievable by human means. After all, if any given state were able to usher in the sort of peace and justice characteristic of God’s kingdom, there would be no reason to hope for the coming of God’s kingdom. We could simply depend on our own efforts.

The Church does not seek to restrain sin through coercion. That role is given to governing authorities. This does not mean that the Church ignores matters of justice. The Church is unique in that it recognizes and seeks to imitate Jesus Christ. As it learns to imitate Jesus, it becomes more just. The Church is marked out as distinct by participating in a constellation of Spirit-empowered practices aimed at conforming God’s people (individually and collectively) to the image of Christ.

The state differs from the Church because the state does not seek to conform to or imitate Christ. As such, the state may have noble aims (e.g., justice and peace) while still differing from and competing with the Church in principle if not in practice. The aim of the state is not to make disciples of Jesus Christ but to form good citizens. “Good citizens” are those who, in the best-case scenario, contribute to efforts intended to bring about some sort of justice, peace, and, increasingly, productivity. The state uses several different mechanisms to shape citizens including, but not limited to, law enforcement, patriotic rituals, and bureaucratic definitions and processes.

As such, the Church is concerned with the work of governing authorities but not satisfied by that work. It is concerned with the state’s work because, as God’s ordained agent for restraining evil, the state often needs to be reminded of its place under God. The Church reminds the state that its authority is from God and to be exercised under his authority. The life, proclamation, and anticipation of the Church point to the state’s provisional nature and the limitations of coercive force to truly transform individuals and society. To remind the state that it is under God’s authority requires God’s people to resist the temptation to depend on the state’s coercive power. The Church’s resistance involves preserving the distinction between Church and state through discipleship.

Both Church and state occupy a shared position under God’s authority. Whether governing authorities recognize that authority or not, they remain subject to the Triune God. The Church and state also share what might be called common human concerns. For instance, many Christians and non-Christians view anarchy as undesirable. Order is preferable to chaos, even though we don’t necessarily agree on what we mean by “order.” Such common concerns should not overshadow the unique theological concerns of the Church. The Church proclaims that nations, no matter how prosperous or moral, cannot establish God’s reign on earth. A “Christian state” or “Christian nation” would be no less provisional than any other state. If we need proof of that, we need only consider Old Testament Israel.

Israel was not founded by devout Christians. It was established by God. He made Israel his unique possession among the nations (Deut 32:8-9; Isa 19:25). Unlike the United States, Israel did not win its freedom through revolution. It was delivered from Egyptian slavery by the hand of God (Exod 15:1-18; Deut 5:6; 6:20-25). Israel’s laws were not crafted by humans with a shared moral center. They were given by God’s own hand (Exod 20:1; 24:12; Deut 5:22). Despite Israel’s advantages, the nation consistently failed to achieve justice and peace. The root cause of this failure involved the inability of God’s law to overcome human sin. If Israel could not overcome human sin despite its unique, God-given advantages, why is it that we think a Christianized version of the United States can?

The Church is not called to rule in the world’s political realm but to point beyond that realm. Yet, the Church is not solely concerned with otherworldly matters. We live in and witness to Christ in the concrete realities of the present age. As such, we are a people trained through discipleship to imitate Christ. Through that preparation, we (a) resist the training of the world and (b) serve the world by serving God and allowing him to work in and through us.

If the Church and the state do not remain distinct, the Church leaves the world without an alternative to the politics of the day. Fusing Christian and nation leaves the nation with nothing more than false hope. Rather than fusing Christian and nation, Christians are to be a people apart. We are to engage the world as disciples prepared to follow Christ even when following Christ appears to leave the world broken. We follow Christ not because doing so fixes the world but because we can conceive of no other way of helping the world than proclaiming the gospel in word and deed. The distinction between the Church and state becomes apparent through the Church’s discipled participation in the world and its systems.

Discipled Participation in the Political Realm

Daniel offers an example of the sort of discipled participation required for Christians to remain faithful amidst the world’s various pressures. When Daniel was taken to Babylon, he was put in the position of participating in Babylonian society. Still, he did not participate in Babylonian society on Nebuchadnezzar’s terms, particularly when those terms compromised his commitment to the Lord. It isn’t just that Daniel refused to sin. Daniel refused to become accustomed to and dependent on Babylonian ways of life.

For instance, Daniel and his friends avoided being “defiled” by eating what the king provided them (Dan 1:8). God sustained them (1:15) and gave them “learning and skill in all literature and wisdom” (1:17). God protected Daniel’s friends in the fiery furnace after they refused to worship Nebuchadnezzar’s golden image (3:1-30). God also kept Daniel safe in the lions’ den when Daniel continued to pray to the Lord despite Darius’s injunction that no one in the kingdom is “to petition god or man for thirty days” except him (6:1-28).

Daniel didn’t seek to reform Babylon, but he (a) took advantage of the opportunities God provided to interpret the dreams of the Babylonian rulers (Dan 2:1-30; 4:4-27) and (b) refused to follow rules that would require him to betray the Lord or cultivate a devotion to Babylon. Daniel’s participation did not compromise his commitment to Israel’s God. Just like Daniel, we participate in society without allowing the priorities and practices of those societies to overshadow our commitment to living faithfully.

God’s people are not responsible for fixing the world, but for living faithfully in a world so broken only God can fix it. For Christians, living faithfully is a non-negotiable and ongoing task. Our commitment to faithful living does not preclude participation in society (or politics). It governs it. When being effective in the political realm requires compromising our Christian character, we opt to be ineffective. When political participation would dilute the Church and its mission, we change course to ensure we do not compromise the Church’s character or distract it from its God-given task. If winning a political battle means aligning ourselves with political powers that diminish our witness to Christ, we opt to lose.

Key Takeaways: Christian Nationalism

  • Core Concepts: Power hunger tempered by self-deception (Orwell); the "soft" vs. "self-aware" forms; the merger of Church and state.
  • Scripture / Scholars: George Orwell; Joseph Mangina (commentary on Revelation); Andrew Whitehead and Samuel Perry; the Neighborly Faith / PRRI surveys; Romans 13; Revelation. Core Distinction: "Inspired by the Bible" is not the same as "living under the authority of the inspired Bible."
  • The "So What": A church that secures Christ's authority through political coercion has already abandoned the method Christ actually commanded: discipleship through witness, not dominion through statecraft.

Read the Whole Argument

This section opens Serpents and Doves, which goes on to develop a theology of public witness that holds Christ’s authority over politics without enlisting him for either party’s cause.

By James Spencer, PhD, theologian and host of the Thinking Christian podcast. His forthcoming book is Digital Discernment: Thinking Rightly in an Age of Misinformation (InterVarsity Press, forthcoming June 2027). About James